Thank you for adding recaptcha support V3 to Nicepage.
However, myself and many others still report a lot of spam.
Would it be possible to add support for V2, even this request form has reCaptcha V2, V3 is simply not sufficient.
I would like et reCaptcha V2 for Nicepage !!
Me 2 V2
> I would like et reCaptcha V2 for Nicepage !! Me 2 V2I would like et reCaptcha V2 for Nicepage !!
I would like et reCaptcha V2 for Nicepage !!Upvote for V2-support. Interesting that Nicepage-devs try to convince the user of V3 and still use V2 in their own forum.
Upvote for V2-support. Interesting that Nicepage-devs try to convince the user of V3 and still use V2 in their own forum.Hi,
Our developers checked the process of connecting reCaptcha v.3 to the Form created in Nicepage and made some changes.
These changes will be available in the next Nicepage 3.18 version. Please wait for this version and check how the form works on your side.
Please let us know the result.
Thank you for being with Nicepage.
...................................................
Sincerely,
Susanna I.
Nicepage Support Team
Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
awsome, looking forward to it.
awsome, looking forward to it.Hi,
Thanks for your comments, we have added your request for reCaptcha v. 2 to our wishlist.
...................................................
Sincerely,
Susanna I.
Nicepage Support Team
Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
The problem is not with using recaptcha v3, but the way it works, and yes we know it's not the fault of NP, it's the fault of Google developers, but, in this case, I would assume that if NP, is getting complaint after complaint after complaint about recaptcha v3, then shouldn't NP dump it, in favor of v2?
You see, the way v3 works is on a scoring system, so initially when a website is setup to use V3, ALL bot spam has a score of 0, thus allowing it through, then while scores are being calculated, the bot generated spam is still being let through, then, as the scores start increasing, the spam will decrease, but this can take days, weeks or even months, depending on how much traffic a site has, and how much the recaptcha v3 is in use, but, this is where v2 out weighs v3 in all aspects, first, a bot can't check the box marked 'I'm not a robot', and second, a bot can't compare images, to determine which image contains a particular object, as in finding images in a recaptcha v2 that has a bicycle, and that even includes just the front wheel, and a bot can't do that, only a human can, which means that some people that have tons of spam to post can't be bothered to mess around with images.
There is also another form of recaptcha that uses an image but part of it removed and presented as a jigsaw piece and you HAVE to use the mouse to move that piece into it's proper slot to continue, you see, any form of recaptcha that is not autonomous and only operated by a human should be acceptable for spam prevention, hence why I chose to use an external script that utilizes recaptcha v2 in my data collection forms (such as contact and comments) on my website created with NP.
The problem is not with using recaptcha v3, but the way it works, and yes we know it's not the fault of NP, it's the fault of Google developers, but, in this case, I would assume that if NP, is getting complaint after complaint after complaint about recaptcha v3, then shouldn't NP dump it, in favor of v2? You see, the way v3 works is on a scoring system, so initially when a website is setup to use V3, ALL bot spam has a score of 0, thus allowing it through, then while scores are being calculated, the bot generated spam is still being let through, then, as the scores start increasing, the spam will decrease, but this can take days, weeks or even months, depending on how much traffic a site has, and how much the recaptcha v3 is in use, but, this is where v2 out weighs v3 in all aspects, first, a bot can't check the box marked 'I'm not a robot', and second, a bot can't compare images, to determine which image contains a particular object, as in finding images in a recaptcha v2 that has a bicycle, and that even includes just the front wheel, and a bot can't do that, only a human can, which means that some people that have tons of spam to post can't be bothered to mess around with images. There is also another form of recaptcha that uses an image but part of it removed and presented as a jigsaw piece and you HAVE to use the mouse to move that piece into it's proper slot to continue, you see, any form of recaptcha that is not autonomous and only operated by a human should be acceptable for spam prevention, hence why I chose to use an external script that utilizes recaptcha v2 in my data collection forms (such as contact and comments) on my website created with NP.Last edited 15 June 2021 by usalabs14
Hi,
Well, there is no badge anywhere on the page at all, which means it
doesn't work.
It looks like the problem is in the reCaptcha keys (you made a mistake when added them under Site Settings >> Google tab or used keys for ReCaptcha v.2).
Please check ReCaptcha settings https://nicepage.com/doc/61415/recaptcha-integration.
If you need further assistance, create a private case and provide your Desktop Project, we will check the problem.
...................................................
Sincerely,
Susanna I.
Nicepage Support Team
Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
Last edited 04 June 2021 by Support Team
Thank you for looking into this.
Thank you for looking into this.Well, there is no badge anywhere on the page at all, which means it doesn't work.
If v3 won't work, and I'm getting tons of spam, then it'll be a case of dumping the contact form and just use the same comments script which can be configured as a contact form, which does use v2 and it works.
Well, there is no badge anywhere on the page at all, which means it doesn't work. If v3 won't work, and I'm getting tons of spam, then it'll be a case of dumping the contact form and just use the same comments script which can be configured as a contact form, which does use v2 and it works.Hi,
I too request recaptcha v2 with the 'I'm not a robot' check box.
We have added your request too.
Please note Nicepage provides you the opportunity to use Google reCAPTCHA v3. If you see the ReCaptcha badge in the bottom right corner of the website, then it works. And Nicepage is not responsible for exactly how it works, efficiently or not.
Also note, reCaptcha v.3 works differently, it analyzes the behavior across an entire site:
https://developers.google.com/recaptcha/docs/v3
https://webmasters.googleblog.com/2018/10/introducing-recaptcha-v3-new-way-to.htm
But our developers will check if there is a problem on our end. We will let you know when we receive a response from them.
...................................................
Sincerely,
Susanna I.
Nicepage Support Team
Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
I too request recaptcha v2 with the 'I'm not a robot' check box.
V3 just doesn't work on the pre-made contact template.
I'm getting tons of spam, and V2 is a lot better than V3, there are more websites that use V2 with the "I;m not a robot" checkbox, than I've seen with V3, I use V2 in the comments section of my website.
I may have to remove any forms from my website created by nicepage, if I can't use recaptcha v2 .
I too request recaptcha v2 with the 'I'm not a robot' check box. V3 just doesn't work on the pre-made contact template. I'm getting tons of spam, and V2 is a lot better than V3, there are more websites that use V2 with the "I;m not a robot" checkbox, than I've seen with V3, I use V2 in the comments section of my website. I may have to remove any forms from my website created by nicepage, if I can't use recaptcha v2 .Last edited 03 June 2021 by usalabs14
I vote for v2 too
It's annoying and I don't have time to implement it myself into exported code
Hi Wouter,
We'll consider your suggestion. Also I believe that Recaptcha 3 algorithm will be further improved.
...................................................
Sincerely,
Hella
Nicepage Support Team
Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
