Contact form anti spam problem

whdmike
56 Posts
whdmike posted this 31 July 2019
Ask a Question

I am really not happy with Nicepage contact form being not more flexible when connected with contact form 7.
The main issue is spam. One option is to add google recaptcha V3, that is slowing down the page. Not good.

There are few other plugins, but they don't work within Nicepage frame.

There is simplest solution within Contact form 7 is simple quiz. This adds simple line to a form
[quiz capital-quiz "The capital of Japan?|Tokyo"] or
[quiz math-quiz "12+48=?|60"]
but doesn't work within nice page.

Can this simple quiz be implemented, should not be a lot of work?

I am really not happy with Nicepage contact form being not more flexible when connected with contact form 7. The main issue is spam. One option is to add google recaptcha V3, that is slowing down the page. Not good. There are few other plugins, but they don't work within Nicepage frame. There is simplest solution within Contact form 7 is simple quiz. This adds simple line to a form [quiz capital-quiz "The capital of Japan?|Tokyo"] or [quiz math-quiz "12+48=?|60"] but doesn't work within nice page. Can this simple quiz be implemented, should not be a lot of work?
Vote to pay developers attention to this features or issue.
10 Replies
Order By: Standard | Newest
whdmike
56 Posts
whdmike posted this 31 July 2019

There is also an option to install Advanced-nocaptcha-recaptcha plugin and you can use recaptcha V2 but you would need to insert a line into contact form 7 [anr_nocaptcha g-recaptcha-response]

There is also an option to install Advanced-nocaptcha-recaptcha plugin and you can use recaptcha V2 but you would need to insert a line into contact form 7 [anr_nocaptcha g-recaptcha-response]
Support Team
Support Team posted this 31 July 2019

Hello,

Nicepage uses reCaptcha v3 because this is the most popular solution and it does not require adding any code to the Nicepage Form.

Unfortunately, I don't know how the quiz plugin that you're using works with all other forms created by various WordPress plugins. But we cannot guarantee that this work with Nicepage form. And unfortunately, the Nicepage Form does not support adding custom HTML on the form. Nicepage uses the CF7 plugin to send an email, but it does not use the cf7 form itself. Therefore if you need exactly the quiz instead of reCaptcha v3, I suggest that you try plain cf7 form which can be inserted using the shortcode on the Nicepage page.

Please let us know if you have any further questions.

...................................................
Sincerely,
Olivia
Nicepage Support Team

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp

Hello, Nicepage uses reCaptcha v3 because this is the most popular solution and it does not require adding any code to the Nicepage Form. Unfortunately, I don't know how the quiz plugin that you're using works with all other forms created by various WordPress plugins. But we cannot guarantee that this work with Nicepage form. And unfortunately, the Nicepage Form does not support adding custom HTML on the form. Nicepage uses the CF7 plugin to send an email, but it does not use the cf7 form itself. Therefore if you need exactly the quiz instead of reCaptcha v3, I suggest that you try plain cf7 form which can be inserted using the shortcode on the Nicepage page. Please let us know if you have any further questions. ................................................... Sincerely, Olivia Nicepage Support Team Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1 Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
whdmike
56 Posts
whdmike posted this 01 August 2019

But there are many problems with captcha V3, like slowing down webpage, unnecessary CSS ...
Try to test your page with google page speed test with and without captcha v3. Big big difference

But there are many problems with captcha V3, like slowing down webpage, unnecessary CSS ... Try to test your page with google page speed test with and without captcha v3. Big big difference
Support Team
Support Team posted this 01 August 2019

Hi Miran,

Thank you for your comments. But the same is related to ReCaptcha v2, embedded video, maps and any other extensions which use external resources. But they are still in used and popular as well as Re Captcha v3. Besides, I sure that google improves it from time to time. ReCaptcha v3 is the modern, popular and most easy to use solution. Unfortunately, we do not plan to implement any other types of captcha in the near future.

Please let us know if you have any further questions.

...................................................
Sincerely,
Olivia
Nicepage Support Team

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp

Hi Miran, Thank you for your comments. But the same is related to ReCaptcha v2, embedded video, maps and any other extensions which use external resources. But they are still in used and popular as well as Re Captcha v3. Besides, I sure that google improves it from time to time. ReCaptcha v3 is the modern, popular and most easy to use solution. Unfortunately, we do not plan to implement any other types of captcha in the near future. Please let us know if you have any further questions. ................................................... Sincerely, Olivia Nicepage Support Team Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1 Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
whdmike
56 Posts
whdmike posted this 02 August 2019

Please do some testing and see for yourself - difference between recaptcha V2 and V3

Please do some testing and see for yourself - difference between recaptcha V2 and V3
Support Team
Support Team posted this 05 August 2019

Hi Miran,

Thank you for your comments. But unfortunately, we do not plan to implement any other captcha types or ReCaptcha v2 in the near future. Please note that you can use any third-part form in combination with Nicepage pages. They should work ok.
Please let us know if you have any further questions.

...................................................
Sincerely,
Olivia
Nicepage Support Team

Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1
Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp

Hi Miran, Thank you for your comments. But unfortunately, we do not plan to implement any other captcha types or ReCaptcha v2 in the near future. Please note that you can use any third-part form in combination with Nicepage pages. They should work ok. Please let us know if you have any further questions. ................................................... Sincerely, Olivia Nicepage Support Team Please subscribe to our YouTube channel: http://youtube.com/nicepage?sub_confirmation=1 Follow us on Facebook: http://facebook.com/nicepageapp
aplicacioneswebs
94 Posts
aplicacioneswebs posted this 06 August 2019

ReCaptcha v3 is more secure and uses other types of technology to detect spam. Hence its slowness, but it is almost imperceptible.

ReCaptcha v3 is more secure and uses other types of technology to detect spam. Hence its slowness, but it is almost imperceptible.
frey2
7 Posts
frey2 posted this 31 March 2023

Like.

Like.

Last edited 05 April 2023 by frey2

@ITS
53 Posts
@ITS posted this 31 October 2023

you can use the "honeypot plugin for contact form 7"
but you must save the field in cf7 after edit the form with nicepage - np overwrite this field when you edit the page/form in np.

maybe can Nicepage integrated this in future for honeypot or not overwrite when edit the cf7 in wp.

now is other bugs with np forms, required fields in checkbox was not set for cf7 and you must also again manually edit in wp after with * to check cf7 is required field. np set this not for checkboxes.

its not a bug, its a feature haha

you can use the "honeypot plugin for contact form 7" but you must save the field in cf7 after edit the form with nicepage - np overwrite this field when you edit the page/form in np. maybe can Nicepage integrated this in future for honeypot or not overwrite when edit the cf7 in wp. now is other bugs with np forms, required fields in checkbox was not set for cf7 and you must also again manually edit in wp after with * to check cf7 is required field. np set this not for checkboxes. its not a bug, its a feature haha

Last edited 31 October 2023 by @ITS

@ITS
53 Posts
@ITS posted this 01 November 2023

[update]
sorry i think maybe this not works... will watch it
maybe nicepage check not the new hidden field when edit after in cf7

i hope nicepage integrate an own honepot field ! is important, than recaptcha is out and not for gpdr

or please compatible to cf7 honeypot plugin

[update] sorry i think maybe this not works... will watch it maybe nicepage check not the new hidden field when edit after in cf7 i hope nicepage integrate an own honepot field ! is important, than recaptcha is out and not for gpdr or please compatible to cf7 honeypot plugin

Last edited 01 November 2023 by @ITS

You must log in or register to leave comments